|
ITM Library - Annual report 2003
|
Electronic journals constitute a rich, diverse, but above all complex
ecosystem. Some of the best thriving species still remain freely accessible
to all, others offer the online edition as part of the standard subscription
but they become available only after explicit registration, through
automatic IP-computer address recognition or a user name/password combination.
Others come at a considerable extra cost, sometimes exceeding the standard
subscription price several times. Major publishers and subscription
agents offer large package deals at a flat fee - often in the context of
library consortia. Paradoxically, this online access to one specific
journal may be more expensive than access to several hundreds of others
combined. As the inherent value of a biomedical journal cannot easily
be compared with just any other, what criteria determine what is a fair
price for what content for which public? Are new initiatives like those
of the open access movement - including Biomed Central and
Public Library of Science journals - a blessing for all involved, when authors - and
their institutions - need to pay a substantial publishing fee, and risk
losing valuable impact factor points in the quest for bibliometric glory?
We endeavour to offer our patrons access to a broad range of electronic
journals, and the acquisition of the EbscoHost Biomedical Reference
Collection, featuring the full-text contents of several years of over
700 biomedical journals, was therefore a major enhancement of our electronic
potential. Another new initiative was the replacement of our remaining
American Society for Microbiology print journals by the full ASM
journals collection in online-only format. As well as improving the ease of access
within ITM, this experiment is certain to limit binding costs and alleviate
the ever-growing physical storage problem. At the moment, however, it does not
seem prudent to consider this a one-size-fits-all solution and cancel all print
subscriptions. The ITM library now offers online access to 130 of the
individual journals it subscribes to. However, taking into account the
packages referred to above, including the Blackwell Science collection
with its 400 titles, our patrons can access over 1,500 biomedial
electronic journal editions.
Optimising access to the electronic journal literature was one of the major
objectives of the library's action plan for 2003, which itself is an
innovation in view of the new institutional quality control programme.
A priority concern was trying to keep an up-to-date survey of the electronic
resources available through a clickable linking list
(http://lib.itg.be/journals.htm).
This list and its sibling
http://lib.itg.be/biblinks.htm for navigating towards useful websites
received a warm recommendation in the latest edition of Manson's Tropical
Diseases (1).
On the databases front, the most important innovation was gaining access to
the ISI Web of Knowledge, featuring the (Social) Science Citation
Index, the Journal Citation Reports (source of the illustrious
journal impact factors and other bibliometric parameters) and Current
Contents Connect.
In this way, ITM finally became a full partner in the Elektron consortium
of the association of Flemish academic and research libraries (VOWB).
Other key elements in the 2003 action plan consisted of the expansion of our
own bibliographic databases, especially the exhaustive Ebola & Marburg Virus
Disease Literature database, and the installation of a security system for
library materials, allowing our visitors to freely take their bags into the
reading rooms.
Another major new initiative is a programme for document delivery and library
support to our overseas partners as part of the institutional co-operation
axis of ITM's framework agreement with DGDC. All partners received a short
guide on where to find freely accessible literature on the Internet (e.g.
using Hinari) and instructions on how to electronically request additional
documents from the ITM library and, upon receipt, to manage these using a
bibliographic database system. Representatives of three partner institutions
took part in a practical workshop on electronic document delivery organised
by the library staff.
As for the more traditional library activities, the core collection of
printed journals remained at the same level, with some 450 current titles.
The printed book collection grew by 465 new titles this year, 297 of them
purchased and 168 obtained for free. The total number of registered books
now exceeds 18,400 and the ITM Library Books and Documents catalogue now
contains over 22,000 titles.
As a logical consequence of the wide availability of electronic collections
at universities and research institutes the number of document requests
from other libraries declined. We supplied 60% of the 2,324 incoming requests
in electronic format, either through the Virtual Library (VirLib) circuit
using Ariel, or directly by e-mail. Of the 1,005 articles we requested
externally, we received 98% in electronic format (PDF) and these were
forwarded in this form to our internal customers. In this category we
mostly made use of a foreign library consortium supplying electronic articles
at favourable rates. This makes document delivery more affordable than
before - especially when compared to 'pay per view' options of commercial
providers charging 25 Euro or more per individual article. Less than 1% of
our external requests could not be fulfilled.
The three library photocopiers together produced over 178,000 copies (this
number includes the printouts of the library staff) - again less than in
previous years, but is a logical development as requests continue being
processed increasingly in a digital fashion. The weekly literature
current-awareness services have also largely been converted from sets of
photocopies to custom made electronic bulletins called TOCAS (Table of
Contents Alert Service).
In the course of 2003, the ERL databases were consulted 25,830 times in
7,548 separate sessions. Our 12 self-produced databases now contain some
70,000 bibliographic descriptions. The 250 different video programmes were
consulted a mere 272 times, but the multimedia CD-ROMs are gaining in
popularity as they are now pre-installed on the 6 public PCs, half of which
were newly acquired.
As before, the introductory sessions on database and Internet searches for
the Masters courses were supplemented with free weekly hands-on workshops.
Library staff also taught several specific Internet introductions in the
International Short Courses and in the new Short Course on
Antiretroviral Treatment (SCART).
In view of the library's commitment to the Southern partners in the DGDC
framework programme, we were happy to welcome Noor Goemaere, a classics
graduate currently studying at the Antwerp library school, as a new part-time
colleague. Meanwhile, Eefje Anthoni, a history graduate, managed to
organise and catalogue the ITM archives.
In addition to the annual internal bibliometric analysis of the ITM scientific
output, the librarian was also involved in the extensive citation analysis
covering 10 years of scientific ITM publications and, as in previous years,
he acted as co-ordinator of the ITM website. In June, a short tour of London
libraries organised by the Flemish library association (VVBAD) gave him the opportunity
to visit our colleagues at the London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine.
ITM scientific publications
The Center for Scientific and Technology Studies (CWTS) of Leiden University
made a thorough analysis of 10 years of ITM scientific publications and their
impact, using the citation databases of the Institute for Scientific
Information (ISI) for 1991-2000. The number of citations (both with and
without self-citations) was counted and compared to global field and journal
category averages. The analysis was carried out on several levels of
aggregation: per institution (all ITM publications combined), per department,
and per unit (the latter only for the years 1996-2000). The major overall
findings were that the 1,025 ITM publications thus identifiable in the
citation databases were cited 10,052 times by other publications represented
in ISI's databases and 'ITM publications are cited well above the level of
world reference values' (2). Various standard indicators are calculated for
the whole 10-year period, and for a time series of 4-year citation windows.
In general, and over the whole period, there is an increase in output, but a
decline in impact, though this remains above the world average. The portion
of never-cited articles decreases, while self-citations increase, but on the
whole do not reach an unusually high level. In particular, fields like (in
order of output) infectious diseases, immunology, general medicine, virology,
microbiology, veterinary sciences and dermatology receive marks significantly
above average. Somewhat surprisingly, tropical medicine and parasitology
(numbers 1 and 3 in output ranking) score below average. As for the different
types of co-authoring, international co-operation (65% of the output) scores
a high impact (1.42 times the world average), as does national co-operation
(15%; 1.34), while 'ITM only' publications have far lower impact rates (20%;
0.69). The impact of non-ISI-source publications could not be taken into
account, but from a sample this appears to be relatively unimportant, except
for some units. Taking into account a number of unquantifiable factors,
the report may highlight 'a slight underestimation of current research
potential'.
There is still more good news from the bibliometric front. Independent from
the specific ITM analysis, a major European Community report was published,
including a chapter on bibliometric data of the European universities,
research institutes and industry labs (3). This was also compiled by CWTS
and based on the ISI citation databases for the years 1993-1999. Again,
it features remarkably good results for the ITM. Obviously, the total number
of ITM publications (702) is far lower than that of bigger institutions
(i.e., not correlated to the actual manpower) when the average impact
(citation based) per publication is compared. However, in the overall field
average, ITM, with a 1.28 ratio, features in 15th place among European
universities and research institutes. As the only smaller Belgian biomedical
institute listed, ITM thus ranks above all other Flemish contenders, and
from a national perspective it is only preceded (narrowly) by UCL (1.30).
The complete bibliographic database of all ITM staff publications is freely
available on the library website ('
http://lib.itg.be/datab.htm').
ITM website
Major innovations during 2003 included an overall restyling of the ITM website
and the integration of the departmental module within a multidimensional menu
for easy navigation. New sections were created for, e.g., the DGDC framework
agreement, the Health Care for All (HCA) initiative, and ITM's annual colloquia.
Also, several sub-websites were developed, such as Telemedicine (HIV therapy),
Eurosupport (also HIV), and various short courses and events. Meanwhile, a
completely renewed version of the ITM intranet was developed. As before, the
more complex innovations were developed in close collaboration with our
Information Technology department and our external partner All Directions.
The log module showed that the ITM website was consulted 269,055 times in 2003,
i.e., about 800 times per weekday. The travel health pages (over 80,000 hits)
were the most popular pages, besides the functional pages such as the home page,
the search page (and sitemap) and the retrievable contact data. The job
vacancies (11,428 hits), the educational pages (master courses: 8,908 hits;
degree courses: 7,152; short courses: 5,266 hits) and 'new on this website'
(5,422 hits) proved to be popular webpages. 69,8% of the 556,904 pages
consulted were in English (the default language!), 22,5% in Dutch, 7,4% in
French and 0.34% in Spanish. In so far as this could be registered, the
majority of visitors came from Belgium, followed by a number of European
countries (e.g., 4,714 hits from The Netherlands). The USA, India, Canada,
Rwanda, Peru and Japan also belong to the top 15 international visitors.
Dirk Schoonbaert
References
- Eyers JE. Sources of information in tropical medicine. In: Cook GC & Zumla
A, Manson's tropical diseases; 21st ed. Edinburgh, Saunders, 2003, 1807-1816.
- Van Leeuwen TN, Visser MS, van der Wurff LJ, van Raan AFJ. Bibliometric
study of the Institute of Tropical Medicine (ITM), Antwerp, Belgium, 1991-2000.
Leiden, Center for Science and Technology Studies (CWTS), 2003. 70 pp. +
appendices.
- Scientific output and impact: Europe's leading role in world science.
In: EC. Third European report on science & technology indicators 2003;
towards a knowledge-based economy. Luxembourg: Office for Official
Publications of the European Communities, 2003: 277-318.
Top